The hardest part of rebuilding a marketing team around AI may be deciding what you cannot afford to lose.
This short, fictional case gives you 90 days in the CMO's chair, with a stalled pipeline, pressure to cut costs, and several defensible choices that carry real risks. Read it, decide what you would do, and bring your perspective to the discussion we're shaping for ANA NorCal's December 10 holiday gathering.
This fictional scenario inspired by common executive challenges. It does not describe a specific ANA NorCal member. | Approximate reading time: four minutes.
At 8:15 on Monday morning, Maya gets a note from the CEO.
Can you meet at 10? We need to talk about the marketing organization.
Maya is the CMO of a growing B2B software company with 160 employees, approximately $30 million in annual recurring revenue, and an 18 person marketing team. The company has ambitious growth targets. Its budget, however, is frozen.
A year ago, the marketing team was overwhelmed by the demands of producing content, supporting campaigns, preparing sales materials, and reporting results. Today, AI tools help it produce drafts, research prospects, create campaign variants, and summarize customer conversations faster than ever.
Output has increased. Pipeline growth has not.
The CEO's request
At 10:00, the CEO gets to the point. If AI is making everyone dramatically more productive, why does marketing still need 18 people?
The CFO has proposed reducing the team by five positions. The CEO wants a plan for a smaller, more effective marketing organization before the next board meeting, 90 days away.
Maya's response is interrupted by the CRO, who has a different view. Sales doesn't need more content, he says. It needs better insight into why deals stall, more convincing proof of value, and help navigating buying committees. He worries that cutting the wrong people will make that problem worse.
The head of product has another complaint: Marketing repeatedly promises capabilities that require qualifications or additional explanation. Technical buyers notice.
Meanwhile, Maya knows the picture inside the team is complicated. A few people have become excellent at designing AI enabled workflows. Others have deep customer expertise that is difficult to replace. Several strong performers have little time to learn new systems. The data is fragmented, the review process is inconsistent, and nobody has established a reliable way to measure how much AI improves outcomes rather than activity.
What would you protect? What would you change?
Maya sees several plausible paths.
She could accept the reduction target and redesign the remaining team around the highest value work. That might satisfy the near term financial pressure, but it risks losing expertise the company will later struggle to rebuild.
She could propose a six month retraining and workflow redesign program, preserving the team while measuring gains in quality, speed, and revenue contribution. But the CEO wants a plan in 90 days, and no one can guarantee the return.
She could move people from traditional departments into groups organized around product adoption, buyer education, and revenue opportunities. That might align work with customer needs, but it would disrupt reporting relationships and raise uncomfortable questions about authority.
Or she could challenge the premise. Perhaps the problem is not that marketing employs too many people, but that the company has optimized production without changing how it identifies, persuades, and serves customers.
Each option may be defensible. None removes the uncertainty.
The decision
The board meeting is in 90 days. Maya must recommend an organizational structure, identify what she would invest in, explain what she would stop doing, and specify how the company will know whether the changes work.
If you were Maya, where would you begin? Would you eliminate roles, retrain people, restructure the department, or question the request itself? Which decisions would you make immediately, and which would you defer until you had better evidence?
Now add one more question.
If you had a magic wand, with no existing org chart, staffing commitments, or legacy systems, what would you build instead?
That's the difference between managing an organization and reinventing one.
Bring your answer into the room
On December 10, ANA NorCal is bringing marketing leaders together for a holiday gathering and a candid Marketing 2030 panel. Our speakers will explore the future of marketing leadership, team structures, emerging skills, and the relationship between marketing and revenue.
We're not asking them to predict 2030 with certainty. We're asking them, and you, how to make consequential decisions when the future is moving quickly.
Share your thinking in our short survey, suggest a question for the panel, and join us for an evening of interesting people and honest conversation.
Thank you to our sponsor: SalesboxAI